Michaelmaylehomes.com Search Results

This listing includes 1661-1663 Ashland Ave. and 1667-1669 Ashland Ave. Two stone front doubles located in the heart of the vibrant Fifth by Northwest District. Buildings must be sold together. All four units offer two spacious bedrooms, rich hardwood floors and private basements with washer/dryer hookups and additional storage. One of the 4 units is available for showings. 1661,1663 and 1667 have been substantially remodeled. 1669 is in good condition with a long term tenant in place. With strong rental demand in this high-growth area, the properties offer solid income potential and excellent long term appreciation. Ample off street parking is available in the rear, and the low-maintenance exterior adds to its turnkey appeal. Whether you're seeking a smart investment or a place to owner occupy, this investment opportunity offers style, function, and location in one of Columbus' most desirable neighborhoods. Walking distance to grocers, restaurants, shopping and bars, as well as the Grandview Ave Entertainment Corridor. 1661 rented through June 2026 at $1700/mo, then MTM 1663 rented through 11/30/2026, at $1500 then MTM 1667 vacant 1669 has long term MTM tenants at $925

⋅ Matthew T Schirtzinger

This listing includes 1661-1663 Ashland Ave. and 1667-1669 Ashland Ave. Two stone front doubles located in the heart of the vibrant Fifth by Northwest District. Buildings must be sold together. All four units offer two spacious bedrooms, rich hardwood floors and private basements with washer/dryer hookups and additional storage. One of the 4 units is available for showings. 1661,1663 and 1667 have been substantially remodeled. 1669 is in good condition with a long term tenant in place. With strong rental demand in this high-growth area, the properties offer solid income potential and excellent long term appreciation. Ample off street parking is available in the rear, and the low-maintenance exterior adds to its turnkey appeal. Whether you're seeking a smart investment or a place to owner occupy, this investment opportunity offers style, function, and location in one of Columbus' most desirable neighborhoods. Walking distance to grocers, restaurants, shopping and bars, as well as the Grandview Ave Entertainment Corridor. 1661 rented through June 2026 at $1700/mo, then MTM 1663 rented through 11/30/2026, at $1500 then MTM 1667 vacant 1669 has long term MTM tenants at $925

1661-1669 Ashland Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Matthew T Schirtzinger ---- RE/MAX Premier Choice

Selling Office: Keller Williams Capital Ptnrs.

$875,000

Curb Offers only. Fully occupied four-unit brick multifamily in the heart of Fifth by Northwest District between Grandview and UA with Columbus taxes. 3,576 SF , 4 two bedroom units with a brick 4-car garage. Current rents: • Three updated units averaging $1,600/month • One long-term tenant at $800/month • Tenants pay all utilities Based on 2024 NOI, the property is operating at a 6% cap rate at list price, with immediate upside through lease adjustments on the under-market unit (market rent ~$1,800 for updated units). Three of four units have been remodeled with updated kitchens, baths, and neutral finishes. The fourth unit offers clear value-add potential. Shared basement, garage parking, and strong tenant demand in one of Columbus' most walkable rental corridors. Consistent occupancy history. Minimal landlord expense structure with tenants covering all utilities. Ideal for: • Investor seeking stable in-place income with upside • 1031 exchange buyer • Owner looking to secure long-term asset in Grandview submarket 2-year P&L and rent roll available in documents. Financials available upon request.

⋅ Matthew T Schirtzinger

Curb Offers only. Fully occupied four-unit brick multifamily in the heart of Fifth by Northwest District between Grandview and UA with Columbus taxes. 3,576 SF , 4 two bedroom units with a brick 4-car garage. Current rents: • Three updated units averaging $1,600/month • One long-term tenant at $800/month • Tenants pay all utilities Based on 2024 NOI, the property is operating at a 6% cap rate at list price, with immediate upside through lease adjustments on the under-market unit (market rent ~$1,800 for updated units). Three of four units have been remodeled with updated kitchens, baths, and neutral finishes. The fourth unit offers clear value-add potential. Shared basement, garage parking, and strong tenant demand in one of Columbus' most walkable rental corridors. Consistent occupancy history. Minimal landlord expense structure with tenants covering all utilities. Ideal for: • Investor seeking stable in-place income with upside • 1031 exchange buyer • Owner looking to secure long-term asset in Grandview submarket 2-year P&L and rent roll available in documents. Financials available upon request.

1500 Fairview Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Matthew T Schirtzinger ---- RE/MAX Premier Choice

Selling Office: Keller Williams Greater Cols.

$545,000

Prime 43212 investment opportunity in one of Columbus' most consistently desirable rental corridors. Brick, stucco and wood, single-story four-unit building featuring four one-bedroom apartments with dedicated entrances and off-street parking. Property is fully occupied with established tenants, providing immediate income from day one. Strong rental history and significant upside potential through rent optimization and value-add improvements over time. Simple, durable construction with low-maintenance exterior. Ample off-street parking and green space enhance tenant appeal. Central location offers quick access to Grandview, OSU, downtown Columbus, major employers, dining, retail, and entertainment -- a proven high-demand rental submarket. Financials, rent roll, and supporting documentation are located in the MLS documents tab. Curb offers only. Do not disturb tenants. Excellent opportunity for investors seeking stabilized cash flow with long-term appreciation in a prime location. Back on the market, see ATA remarks

⋅ Matthew T Schirtzinger

Prime 43212 investment opportunity in one of Columbus' most consistently desirable rental corridors. Brick, stucco and wood, single-story four-unit building featuring four one-bedroom apartments with dedicated entrances and off-street parking. Property is fully occupied with established tenants, providing immediate income from day one. Strong rental history and significant upside potential through rent optimization and value-add improvements over time. Simple, durable construction with low-maintenance exterior. Ample off-street parking and green space enhance tenant appeal. Central location offers quick access to Grandview, OSU, downtown Columbus, major employers, dining, retail, and entertainment -- a proven high-demand rental submarket. Financials, rent roll, and supporting documentation are located in the MLS documents tab. Curb offers only. Do not disturb tenants. Excellent opportunity for investors seeking stabilized cash flow with long-term appreciation in a prime location. Back on the market, see ATA remarks

1461-1467 Chesapeake Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Matthew T Schirtzinger ---- RE/MAX Premier Choice

Selling Office: Berkshire Hathaway HS Pro Rlty.

$545,000

Welcome to this beautifully updated three-story home in the heart of The Fifth by Northwest District--one of Columbus' most vibrant and walkable neighborhoods. Offering 1,974 square feet of thoughtfully refreshed living space, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home blends timeless character with modern finishes. The inviting front porch sets the tone, leading into a bright, open main level with LVT flooring, fresh neutral paint, and abundant natural light. The spacious living and dining areas flow effortlessly, anchored by a decorative fireplace feature wall that adds warmth and architectural interest. The fully renovated kitchen is a standout, featuring crisp white cabinetry, quartz countertops, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and sleek black fixtures. Designed for both daily living and entertaining, it offers generous prep space and storage. The second floor offers two well-proportioned bedrooms providing flexibility for guests, office space, or family living. The two updated full baths showcase clean, contemporary finishes. The third-story level offers an additional bedroom. A full basement provides excellent storage. Outside, enjoy a large patio for entertaining, a fenced yard and rare two-car garage. Just around the corner from neighborhood favorites along the Grandview Ave Entertainment Corridor, parks, restaurants, coffee shops, and minutes to OSU and downtown, this home delivers the ultimate urban lifestyle with classic charm and modern comfort.

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Matthew T Schirtzinger

Welcome to this beautifully updated three-story home in the heart of The Fifth by Northwest District--one of Columbus' most vibrant and walkable neighborhoods. Offering 1,974 square feet of thoughtfully refreshed living space, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home blends timeless character with modern finishes. The inviting front porch sets the tone, leading into a bright, open main level with LVT flooring, fresh neutral paint, and abundant natural light. The spacious living and dining areas flow effortlessly, anchored by a decorative fireplace feature wall that adds warmth and architectural interest. The fully renovated kitchen is a standout, featuring crisp white cabinetry, quartz countertops, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, and sleek black fixtures. Designed for both daily living and entertaining, it offers generous prep space and storage. The second floor offers two well-proportioned bedrooms providing flexibility for guests, office space, or family living. The two updated full baths showcase clean, contemporary finishes. The third-story level offers an additional bedroom. A full basement provides excellent storage. Outside, enjoy a large patio for entertaining, a fenced yard and rare two-car garage. Just around the corner from neighborhood favorites along the Grandview Ave Entertainment Corridor, parks, restaurants, coffee shops, and minutes to OSU and downtown, this home delivers the ultimate urban lifestyle with classic charm and modern comfort.

1624 Ashland Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Matthew T Schirtzinger ---- RE/MAX Premier Choice

Selling Office: Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs.

$425,000

Interior photos available with a signed NDA. Financials in the documents section. Positioned in one of Columbus' most consistently in-demand pockets, this Fifth by Northwest double offers a steady income stream. Both sides are rented with tenants on a month to month basis, allowing for the opportunity for an Owner Occupant. The property offers practical layouts, separate entrances, and off-street parking, along with private basement space with washer/dryer hook ups. Situated on a large lot with ample green space and room for garages and an ADU. Amazing location--nestled between Grandview Avenue and Upper Arlington. Conveniently located close to The Ohio State University. Walkability to dining, shopping, and everyday amenities continues to drive strong demand in this corridor, supporting both rental stability and long-term appreciation. A flexible opportunity in a proven location--ideal for buyers who want both a place to live and an asset that works for them or for someone looking for a low maintenance investment property.

⋅ Matthew T Schirtzinger

Interior photos available with a signed NDA. Financials in the documents section. Positioned in one of Columbus' most consistently in-demand pockets, this Fifth by Northwest double offers a steady income stream. Both sides are rented with tenants on a month to month basis, allowing for the opportunity for an Owner Occupant. The property offers practical layouts, separate entrances, and off-street parking, along with private basement space with washer/dryer hook ups. Situated on a large lot with ample green space and room for garages and an ADU. Amazing location--nestled between Grandview Avenue and Upper Arlington. Conveniently located close to The Ohio State University. Walkability to dining, shopping, and everyday amenities continues to drive strong demand in this corridor, supporting both rental stability and long-term appreciation. A flexible opportunity in a proven location--ideal for buyers who want both a place to live and an asset that works for them or for someone looking for a low maintenance investment property.

1610-1612 Ashland Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Matthew T Schirtzinger ---- RE/MAX Premier Choice

Selling Office: Keller Williams Consultants.

$250,000

Rare offering in one of Columbus' most sought after neighborhoods. This two bedroom, one bath home offers 768 sq ft of potential on a deep lot surrounded by strong values and vibrant development. Built in 1940, the property is in need of renovation and is being sold as-is. Ideal for investors, builders, or Buyers seeking a renovation opportunity. Positioned steps from restaurants, shops, parks and neighborhood amenities, the location is the true highlight.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Matthew T Schirtzinger

Rare offering in one of Columbus' most sought after neighborhoods. This two bedroom, one bath home offers 768 sq ft of potential on a deep lot surrounded by strong values and vibrant development. Built in 1940, the property is in need of renovation and is being sold as-is. Ideal for investors, builders, or Buyers seeking a renovation opportunity. Positioned steps from restaurants, shops, parks and neighborhood amenities, the location is the true highlight.

1493 Chesapeake Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Matthew T Schirtzinger ---- RE/MAX Premier Choice

Selling Office: RZ Realty.

$1,700

GORGEOUS GRANDVIEW AREA TOWNHOME! Fully renovated with the right blend of character and modern updates, this Grandview area townhome offers a fresh, inviting feel from the moment you walk in. Refinished hardwood floors bring warmth and charm, while the crisp white kitchen with quartz countertops and new stainless steel appliances deliver a clean, updated look. The renovated bath and new fixtures throughout complete the space with a cohesive, move-in ready finish. The layout is both functional and comfortable, featuring private basement space with washer/dryer hookups, additional storage, and convenient off-street parking. Set on a large lot with generous green space, this location truly stands out, tucked between Grandview Avenue and Upper Arlington, just minutes from The Ohio State University and downtown. Enjoy easy walkability to dining, shopping, and everyday amenities, all in one of Columbus' most consistently desirable and high-demand areas.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Paula Koontz Gilmour

GORGEOUS GRANDVIEW AREA TOWNHOME! Fully renovated with the right blend of character and modern updates, this Grandview area townhome offers a fresh, inviting feel from the moment you walk in. Refinished hardwood floors bring warmth and charm, while the crisp white kitchen with quartz countertops and new stainless steel appliances deliver a clean, updated look. The renovated bath and new fixtures throughout complete the space with a cohesive, move-in ready finish. The layout is both functional and comfortable, featuring private basement space with washer/dryer hookups, additional storage, and convenient off-street parking. Set on a large lot with generous green space, this location truly stands out, tucked between Grandview Avenue and Upper Arlington, just minutes from The Ohio State University and downtown. Enjoy easy walkability to dining, shopping, and everyday amenities, all in one of Columbus' most consistently desirable and high-demand areas.

1654 Ashland Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Paula Koontz Gilmour ---- KW Classic Properties Realty

Selling Office: KW Classic Properties Realty.

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?