Michaelmaylehomes.com Search Results

METICULOUSLY MAINTAINED AND THOUGHTFULLY UPDATED! This 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom brick Italianate is situated in the most perfect Italian Village/Short North location. This home blends modern updates with historic character! Quality craftsmanship throughout. Light, bright and airy describe the open first floor. The large living room features custom built-ins, an original fireplace mantle and surround and hardwood floors that lead into the dining room. Gorgeous custom kitchen remodel with every inch of space designed with functionality in mind. A chef's dream! Shaker style cherry cabinets, under cabinet lighting, granite countertops, undermounted dual bowl ss sink, tile backsplash, new 36' dual fuel (gas and electric) stainless steel range, french door refrigerator, custom pantry cabinets and window seat. Renovated first floor full bathroom with curbless shower! A private, fully fenced rear yard with brick paver patio and lush landscaping is the perfect place to entertain. The primary bedroom offers an attached walk-in closet with custom built-ins and access to the renovated full bathroom which features a double vanity with marble countertop and plenty of storage, ceramic tile shower surround and ceramic tile floors. A true second floor laundry - a rare find for the area - which accommodates a side-by-side washer/dryer and great storage space! Additional bedroom with large closet and original fireplace surround. 2.5 car detached garage provides great space for additional storage options. Close proximity to the best restaurants and galleries Columbus has to offer. Minutes from downtown, German Village, the airport, Easton and more. Extensive list of updates available upon request! A true GEM you have to see to appreciate.

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Brandon T Prewitt

METICULOUSLY MAINTAINED AND THOUGHTFULLY UPDATED! This 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom brick Italianate is situated in the most perfect Italian Village/Short North location. This home blends modern updates with historic character! Quality craftsmanship throughout. Light, bright and airy describe the open first floor. The large living room features custom built-ins, an original fireplace mantle and surround and hardwood floors that lead into the dining room. Gorgeous custom kitchen remodel with every inch of space designed with functionality in mind. A chef's dream! Shaker style cherry cabinets, under cabinet lighting, granite countertops, undermounted dual bowl ss sink, tile backsplash, new 36' dual fuel (gas and electric) stainless steel range, french door refrigerator, custom pantry cabinets and window seat. Renovated first floor full bathroom with curbless shower! A private, fully fenced rear yard with brick paver patio and lush landscaping is the perfect place to entertain. The primary bedroom offers an attached walk-in closet with custom built-ins and access to the renovated full bathroom which features a double vanity with marble countertop and plenty of storage, ceramic tile shower surround and ceramic tile floors. A true second floor laundry - a rare find for the area - which accommodates a side-by-side washer/dryer and great storage space! Additional bedroom with large closet and original fireplace surround. 2.5 car detached garage provides great space for additional storage options. Close proximity to the best restaurants and galleries Columbus has to offer. Minutes from downtown, German Village, the airport, Easton and more. Extensive list of updates available upon request! A true GEM you have to see to appreciate.

684 Kerr Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Brandon T Prewitt ---- RE/MAX Partners

$495,000

In Italian Village near the Short North, this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath brick home pairs a private fenced backyard with an oversized detached carriageway garage and flexible third-floor living space. Major improvements include a new HVAC system (2025), new electrical panel and exterior outlets, along with fresh paint throughout. The main level flows from the living room into the dining area and kitchen with white cabinetry, butcher block counters and stainless appliances, plus a half bath. Two bedrooms and an updated full bath are on the second floor, while the finished third floor can serve as a bedroom or additional living space. Outside, a cedar fence surrounds the backyard with a paver patio, while a new concrete slab sits in front of the garage. A covered front porch adds another place to enjoy the neighborhood. The full basement provides laundry and storage and includes new glass block, while the garage features a built-in workbench.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Robert J Riddle

In Italian Village near the Short North, this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath brick home pairs a private fenced backyard with an oversized detached carriageway garage and flexible third-floor living space. Major improvements include a new HVAC system (2025), new electrical panel and exterior outlets, along with fresh paint throughout. The main level flows from the living room into the dining area and kitchen with white cabinetry, butcher block counters and stainless appliances, plus a half bath. Two bedrooms and an updated full bath are on the second floor, while the finished third floor can serve as a bedroom or additional living space. Outside, a cedar fence surrounds the backyard with a paver patio, while a new concrete slab sits in front of the garage. A covered front porch adds another place to enjoy the neighborhood. The full basement provides laundry and storage and includes new glass block, while the garage features a built-in workbench.

943 Mount Pleasant Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Robert J Riddle ---- New Albany Realty, LTD

$399,999

Historic Brick Home in Italian Village Under $400K! Discover an incredible opportunity to own a piece of Columbus history at 41 E Prescott Street! Built in 1850, this charming all-brick home offers approximately 1,470 square feet, 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and 1 half bath in the heart of Italian Village, just steps from the vibrant Short North Arts District. Blending timeless architectural character with everyday functionality, this home features flexible living and dining spaces ideal for entertaining, relaxing, or creating a dedicated home office. With many major improvements already completed, the interior offers an exciting opportunity to add your personal style and finishing touches while building potential equity. A full basement provides generous storage space, while the private outdoor patio creates the perfect setting for morning coffee, weekend gatherings, or quiet evenings at home. Enjoy the benefits of outdoor living without the upkeep of a large yard! LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Experience the convenience of living near some of Columbus's most popular destinations. Walk to the Short North, North Market, neighborhood restaurants, coffee shops, breweries, boutiques, and entertainment. Downtown Columbus, the Arena District, Ohio State University, and Nationwide Children's Hospital are all easily accessible, along with I-670 and I-71. Whether you're searching for your first home, looking to downsize, or seeking a historic property with character and potential, this Italian Village gem offers an exceptional opportunity at its newly adjusted price. Historic charm, private outdoor space, and an unbeatable urban location--all under $400K! Schedule your showing and discover the possibilities!

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Joseph R Speakman

Historic Brick Home in Italian Village Under $400K! Discover an incredible opportunity to own a piece of Columbus history at 41 E Prescott Street! Built in 1850, this charming all-brick home offers approximately 1,470 square feet, 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and 1 half bath in the heart of Italian Village, just steps from the vibrant Short North Arts District. Blending timeless architectural character with everyday functionality, this home features flexible living and dining spaces ideal for entertaining, relaxing, or creating a dedicated home office. With many major improvements already completed, the interior offers an exciting opportunity to add your personal style and finishing touches while building potential equity. A full basement provides generous storage space, while the private outdoor patio creates the perfect setting for morning coffee, weekend gatherings, or quiet evenings at home. Enjoy the benefits of outdoor living without the upkeep of a large yard! LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Experience the convenience of living near some of Columbus's most popular destinations. Walk to the Short North, North Market, neighborhood restaurants, coffee shops, breweries, boutiques, and entertainment. Downtown Columbus, the Arena District, Ohio State University, and Nationwide Children's Hospital are all easily accessible, along with I-670 and I-71. Whether you're searching for your first home, looking to downsize, or seeking a historic property with character and potential, this Italian Village gem offers an exceptional opportunity at its newly adjusted price. Historic charm, private outdoor space, and an unbeatable urban location--all under $400K! Schedule your showing and discover the possibilities!

41 E Prescott Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Joseph R Speakman ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$385,000

Stylishly updated sunny 2-story shared-wall townhome-style single-family house (not a condo; no HOA or COA) w/lovely private patio, a short walk from base of Short North, Convention Center, Arena District, and popular Italian Village attractions. Buy it as a primary residence or turnkey furnished rental (currently a successful, licensed AirBnB short-term rental). Main level has spacious kitchen w/navy cabinets, butcher block counters & SS appliances; full dining room & large living room with/original fireplace & trim details. Upstairs has 2 private bedrooms and full bathroom. Larger bedroom has wall of built-ins for storage and home office. Recent improvements include new gas furnace & water heater (2026), Wi-Fi enabled Schlage keypad deadbolt locks, Nest thermostat, and Ring Video Doorbells helpful for managing STR tenancies. Short North Parking Plan Zone SNB street parking pass available for $25/yr. Showings need to be scheduled around current AirBnB stays.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Nathan R Caplin

Stylishly updated sunny 2-story shared-wall townhome-style single-family house (not a condo; no HOA or COA) w/lovely private patio, a short walk from base of Short North, Convention Center, Arena District, and popular Italian Village attractions. Buy it as a primary residence or turnkey furnished rental (currently a successful, licensed AirBnB short-term rental). Main level has spacious kitchen w/navy cabinets, butcher block counters & SS appliances; full dining room & large living room with/original fireplace & trim details. Upstairs has 2 private bedrooms and full bathroom. Larger bedroom has wall of built-ins for storage and home office. Recent improvements include new gas furnace & water heater (2026), Wi-Fi enabled Schlage keypad deadbolt locks, Nest thermostat, and Ring Video Doorbells helpful for managing STR tenancies. Short North Parking Plan Zone SNB street parking pass available for $25/yr. Showings need to be scheduled around current AirBnB stays.

729 Kerr Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Nathan R Caplin ---- CapOhio Real Estate

$369,000

Italian Village | Columbus, OH | 2 BD | 1.5 BA Location is the first thing buyers notice here, and it delivers. This two-bedroom, 1.5 bath townhome sits on a quiet street in Italian Village, one of Columbus' most walkable and in-demand neighborhoods, with the Short North, Goodale Park, and some of the city's best restaurants and coffee shops nearby. The address alone puts this property on a short list. Inside, hardwood floors run throughout the main living areas. Tall ceilings and exposed brick add the kind of architectural character that newer construction cannot replicate. Natural light moves through the space generously, making it feel larger than the square footage suggests. The kitchen includes newer stainless steel appliances and connects to a large dining area, keeping the main level open and functional. A gated entry provides a sense of arrival and added privacy that stands out in an urban setting. Upstairs, two spacious bedrooms both feature vaulted ceilings. The bathroom has been completely renovated with a walk-in shower, soaking tub, and double sinks. Step outside to a private, fenced patio. For a property this close to the energy of the Short North, having an outdoor space that actually feels removed from it is a meaningful feature. A basement includes a newer washer and dryer and adds storage. A one-car garage rounds out a package that is genuinely difficult to find at this location. This property functions equally well as a primary residence or an income-producing rental asset. Proximity to the convention center, Ohio State Medical Center, and the downtown employment core makes this an ideal location.

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Karen S Smith

Italian Village | Columbus, OH | 2 BD | 1.5 BA Location is the first thing buyers notice here, and it delivers. This two-bedroom, 1.5 bath townhome sits on a quiet street in Italian Village, one of Columbus' most walkable and in-demand neighborhoods, with the Short North, Goodale Park, and some of the city's best restaurants and coffee shops nearby. The address alone puts this property on a short list. Inside, hardwood floors run throughout the main living areas. Tall ceilings and exposed brick add the kind of architectural character that newer construction cannot replicate. Natural light moves through the space generously, making it feel larger than the square footage suggests. The kitchen includes newer stainless steel appliances and connects to a large dining area, keeping the main level open and functional. A gated entry provides a sense of arrival and added privacy that stands out in an urban setting. Upstairs, two spacious bedrooms both feature vaulted ceilings. The bathroom has been completely renovated with a walk-in shower, soaking tub, and double sinks. Step outside to a private, fenced patio. For a property this close to the energy of the Short North, having an outdoor space that actually feels removed from it is a meaningful feature. A basement includes a newer washer and dryer and adds storage. A one-car garage rounds out a package that is genuinely difficult to find at this location. This property functions equally well as a primary residence or an income-producing rental asset. Proximity to the convention center, Ohio State Medical Center, and the downtown employment core makes this an ideal location.

1103 Mount Pleasant Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Karen S Smith ---- The Brokerage House

$150,000

RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN ONE OF THE LAST AVAILABLE BUILDING LOTS IN HIGHLY DESIRABLE ITALIAN VILLAGE! Whether you're looking to build a custom owner-occupied residence or capitalize on an exceptional development opportunity, this property offers tremendous potential in one of Columbus' most sought-after neighborhoods. Surrounded by luxury new construction, with nearby homes selling from the upper $800,000s to well over $1 million, the possibilities are endless. Enjoy a premier location just steps from neighborhood shops, restaurants, parks, and the vibrant High Street and Short North districts. Conveniently located minutes from Downtown Columbus, The Ohio State University, and major employment centers. AGGRESSIVELY PRICED AND READY FOR DEVELOPMENT. OPPORTUNITIES LIKE THIS ARE BECOMING INCREASINGLY RARE IN ITALIAN VILLAGE!

⋅ Michael A Casey

RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN ONE OF THE LAST AVAILABLE BUILDING LOTS IN HIGHLY DESIRABLE ITALIAN VILLAGE! Whether you're looking to build a custom owner-occupied residence or capitalize on an exceptional development opportunity, this property offers tremendous potential in one of Columbus' most sought-after neighborhoods. Surrounded by luxury new construction, with nearby homes selling from the upper $800,000s to well over $1 million, the possibilities are endless. Enjoy a premier location just steps from neighborhood shops, restaurants, parks, and the vibrant High Street and Short North districts. Conveniently located minutes from Downtown Columbus, The Ohio State University, and major employment centers. AGGRESSIVELY PRICED AND READY FOR DEVELOPMENT. OPPORTUNITIES LIKE THIS ARE BECOMING INCREASINGLY RARE IN ITALIAN VILLAGE!

1152 Summit Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Michael A Casey ---- RE/MAX Connection

$2,100

Italian Village | Columbus, OH | 2 BD | 1.5 BA Location is the first thing renters will notice here, and it delivers. This two-bedroom, 1.5 bath townhome sits on a quiet street in Italian Village, one of Columbus' most walkable and in-demand neighborhoods, with the Short North, Goodale Park, and some of the city's best restaurants and coffee shops nearby. The address alone puts this property on a short list. Inside, hardwood floors run throughout the main living areas. Tall ceilings and exposed brick add the kind of architectural character that newer construction cannot replicate. Natural light moves through the space generously, making it feel larger than the square footage suggests. The kitchen includes newer stainless steel appliances and connects to a large dining area, keeping the main level open and functional. A gated entry provides a sense of arrival and added privacy that stands out in an urban setting. Upstairs, two spacious bedrooms both feature vaulted ceilings. The bathroom has been completely renovated with a walk-in shower, soaking tub, and double sinks. Step outside to a private, fenced patio. For a property this close to the energy of the Short North, having an outdoor space that actually feels removed from it is a meaningful feature. A basement includes a newer washer and dryer and adds storage. A one-car garage rounds out a package that is genuinely difficult to find at this location.

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Karen S Smith

Italian Village | Columbus, OH | 2 BD | 1.5 BA Location is the first thing renters will notice here, and it delivers. This two-bedroom, 1.5 bath townhome sits on a quiet street in Italian Village, one of Columbus' most walkable and in-demand neighborhoods, with the Short North, Goodale Park, and some of the city's best restaurants and coffee shops nearby. The address alone puts this property on a short list. Inside, hardwood floors run throughout the main living areas. Tall ceilings and exposed brick add the kind of architectural character that newer construction cannot replicate. Natural light moves through the space generously, making it feel larger than the square footage suggests. The kitchen includes newer stainless steel appliances and connects to a large dining area, keeping the main level open and functional. A gated entry provides a sense of arrival and added privacy that stands out in an urban setting. Upstairs, two spacious bedrooms both feature vaulted ceilings. The bathroom has been completely renovated with a walk-in shower, soaking tub, and double sinks. Step outside to a private, fenced patio. For a property this close to the energy of the Short North, having an outdoor space that actually feels removed from it is a meaningful feature. A basement includes a newer washer and dryer and adds storage. A one-car garage rounds out a package that is genuinely difficult to find at this location.

1103 Mount Pleasant Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Karen S Smith ---- The Brokerage House

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?